How Rescue Swimmers
Survive in Cold Water
16 March 2023 | By RSM Vince
WARNING:
Though we will be covering the benefits of cold therapy, individuals should consult with their physicians prior to undergoing the stresses of cold immersion. Regardless of physical health, it is important to progress gradually to allow one's body to grow accustomed to these stresses.
Military Cold Water History
When attending Helicopter Rescue Swimmer school in the winter of 2013, my peers and I all subscribed to what we called "The Church of Petty Officer Holt". Tyler Holt, now a rescue swimmer Chief Petty Officer, was our guru of Health and Fitness. Today, he's earned a Master's degree in that exact field.
During his time as a Coast Guard Helicopter Rescue Swimmer instructor, Holt was influential in many of the changes that occurred in candidate training and development at the North Carolina training center. This included:
Though Holt was wary to avoid telling us directly to perform cold therapy, he did share the benefits of his own daily cold rituals. Note: This was well before most of us had been influenced by the Wim Hoff method hitting mainstream media.
Needless to say, it wasn't long before, every day, base personnel would slow down their vehicles to observe the group of crazy, half-naked rescue swimmer candidates, immersed in the waters of the Pasquotank River in freezing winter temperatures. Music and cackles filled the air as we'd dip those 10min every day.
So why would we torture ourselves so?
Latest Posts
How Rescue Swimmers Save Lives
21 November 2022
How to Get Faster in the Water Now
16 August 2022
3 Lifeguard Drills to Improve your Water Confidence
29 October 2018
Related Courses
During stresses of life, just like in cold therapy,
never underestimate the power of a prolonged exhale.
The Science
The WHY
BUDS candidates know uncomfortably cold water more than most. Typically, the water temperatures in San Diego reach a high of 69°F and drop into the low 50's during the winter. In their training, SEAL candidates have developed a method of postponing hypothermia by shutting down their shivering response. Nevertheless, their body temperatures still drop, allowing them to achieve the benefits of hypothermia: a slower metabolism and lowered oxygen requirements which extends their dive time.
The WHEN
Often less discussed is our body's temperature fluctuation associated with our circadian rhythm. Roughly, your core temperature is at it's lowest approximately 2hrs prior to waking up. Your temperature then continues to rise, peaking at it's highest temperature in the mid to late afternoon.
It is valuable to keep this in mind for when you choose to use cold therapy — early mornings and late evenings will offer a more difficult mental and physical challenge.
Typically, following the first 15-30sec "shock period", you will calm down. I would recommend you occasionally stay in past that next "wall" period, which often comes between 2-4min after the initial submersion. As your body thermo-regulates, these walls will intermittently come and go, continuously challenging your mental fortitude.
PRO TIP: Instead of setting yourself timed goals, try setting yourself a set number of "walls" to overcome prior to starting every session.
Eg: One day you might just want to submerge and overcome that first "shock wall" in extremely cold water, while other days you might set yourself the goal of overcoming 2 walls of challenge within slightly less cold temperatures.
Few peer reviewed studies cover this topic, though some mention 11min total per week divided into 2-4 sessions of 2-3min.
The HOW
Here are the most common/accessible types of cold therapy in order of most effective to least:
Note: Cold water submersion creates > 4 times more heat transfer than cold air.
Uncomfortably cold to the point where you want to quit but you can safely keep going.
What should your mental state be? You basically have 2 options:
NOTE: Challenging your pre-frontal cortex by doing math problems or trying to remember specific quotes/songs are valuable methods of training your brain to think while under tremendous stress (a crucial tool for any elite military professional).
If one stays still, the body expels heat thus creating a thermal layer around the body (kind of like a wetsuit). Movement breaks that thermal layer. So if you'd like to experience much colder temperatures and challenge your resilience even further; movement and/or river plunges can be, a fun variable to play with.
NOTE: If ever lost at sea, one can prolong their survivability in cold water by raising their legs and creating a bubble of warmer water. This same method can be used when in a group, by having everyone tread side-by-side in a circle with their feet raised and pointing inwardly.
Though challenging at times, implementing a long exhale when first entering the cold water has a surprisingly soothing/grounding effect on the mind. Aside from the fact that our heart rates slow during exhales, I find that inhaling feels very labored (almost like an asthmatic feeling) when one first enters the water. This can have the effect of inducing a feeling of panic.
The exhale, on the other hand, creates a calming effect. I've therefore concluded that the common saying "Take a deep breath in" when undergoing the traumatic stresses of life is false, rather than the more fitting phrase: "Release a long exhale".
Nevertheless, if time permits, trying the Wim Hoff breathing method can be a worthwhile experiment. Here's how to do it:
Some of the benefits associated with this breathing exercises include:
WARNING: DO NOT combine the Wim Hoff breathing method with underwater breath holding exercises. Wim Hoff's breathing cycle induces hyperventilation which purges out CO2 (the body's natural mechanism that reminds us to breath). Combining Wim Hoff's method with apnea drills can very easily cause shallow water blackouts. We've dedicated an entire chapter of the Hold your Breath like a Helicopter Rescue Swimmer course to that exact topic.
Cold Water = Slowed Heart Rate = Longer Breath Holds
The Power of the exhale during initial submersion.
Helps train our ability to stay calm during fight-or-flight response.
Increased epinephrine means better focus, and drive.
How Cold? ...as cold as you can uncomfortably tolerate safely.
Stillness creates a thermal layer.
Movement means increased cold.How
Cold Water Clips
At 5:56 in this video, RSM Vince and Cody review the famous hypothermia scene in the 2006 film The Guardian.
RSM Tips for Cold Water Immersion. Watch as Vince freezes his nuts off in <-20°C winter air temps in Canmore, Canada.
Stanford University School of Medicine professor Andrew D. Huberman discusses the in depth science behind cold therapy.
Rescue Swimmer Mindset
Podcast
Listen as RSM Vince and Men's Mental Health Specialist, Calen Martents, discuss cold therapy, unhealthy coping mechanisms, social media addiction, breath-work, meditation, healthy habits and how elite athletes can better their physical and mental well-being.